Security Advisory

CVE-2019-10984: Red Lion Crimson File Pointer Mishandling

Last updated:
  • CVE-2019-10984

CVE-2019-10984 is a pointer-handling flaw in Red Lion Crimson, the Windows software used to program Red Lion HMIs and gateways. A crafted CD3 or CD31 file makes Crimson use an uninitialised or attacker-controlled pointer, which can run the attacker's code when a user opens the file. NVD scores it 7.8. Crimson 3.0 and earlier and 3.1 before release 3112.00 are affected; Crimson 3.1 release 3112.00 fixes it.

Vulnerability summary

CVSS base score

7.8

High severity

EPSS score (FIRST)

1.0%

Probability of exploitation in the wild in the next 30 days

CISA KEV catalog

No

Not listed

Published

Vulnerability ID: CVE-2019-10984 · Source: NVD

Affected components

ComponentCPEVersion range
Red Lion Crimson (Windows configuration software)cpe:2.3:a:redlion:crimson:*:*:*:*:*:*:*:*Crimson 3.0 and earlier, and Crimson 3.1 before release 3112.00 (CISA ICSA-19-248-01; NVD CPE: up to and including 3.0, and from 3.1 up to but excluding 3112.00); fix: Crimson 3.1 release 3112.00 or later

What does this mean for affected devices?

NVD carries the CISA-assigned description: Crimson 3.0 and earlier and Crimson 3.1 before release 3112.00 "allow multiple vulnerabilities to be exploited when a valid user opens a specially crafted, malicious input file that causes the program to mishandle pointers." The record was published on 2019-09-23 (NVD, CVE record).

How severe is it, and which CWE applies?

NVD's Primary score is CVSS v3.1 7.8 (CVSS:3.1/AV:L/AC:L/PR:N/UI:R/S:U/C:H/I:H/A:H), with a CVSS v2 score of 6.8. CISA's ICSA-19-248-01 CSAF file gives the same 7.8 vector as CVSS v3.0, and CISA's ADP entry on NVD repeats it. The weakness label differs by source: the ICS-CERT CNA record says CWE-465 (pointer issues), the CISA CSAF file says CWE-824 (access of uninitialized pointer), and NVD's own entry is NVD-CWE-Other. All three describe the same bug class: Crimson uses a pointer it has not validated or initialised.

What does the flaw look like?

Trend Micro's Zero Day Initiative mapped three reports to this CVE in its published 2019 list. ZDI-19-786 is in CD3 file parsing and "results from the lack of proper initialization of a pointer prior to accessing it". ZDI-19-789 is in CD31 file parsing, where Crimson dereferences a user-supplied value as a pointer without validating it; ZDI says this one lets an attacker execute code "in the context of Administrator". ZDI-19-791 is a further untrusted pointer dereference in CD3 files. All three need a user to open the crafted file in Crimson. ZDI reported them to Red Lion on 2019-02-28 and published on 2019-09-05.

Which products are affected, and is there a fix?

Product Affected Fix
Red Lion Crimson 3.0 3.0 and earlier Migrate to Crimson 3.1 release 3112.00 or later where the device model allows
Red Lion Crimson 3.1 Before release 3112.00 Crimson 3.1 release 3112.00 or later

CISA's remediation text is that Red Lion "recommends users migrate to Crimson 3.1 release 3112.00 or later where the model choice allows", and Red Lion published a security bulletin for the set. NVD's CPE configuration matches the same two ranges. Check that each HMI or gateway in a project is supported by Crimson 3.1 before moving it.

How do you mitigate it?

ZDI-19-789's note about Administrator context is a reason to stop running Crimson from an administrator account: on a standard account, code execution in the Crimson process gets that user's rights rather than control of the workstation. Update Crimson on every machine that has it, open only Crimson files from known colleagues or a controlled repository, and do not open project files received by unsolicited email, as CISA's social-engineering guidance advises. CISA reported no known public exploits specifically targeting these vulnerabilities.

ICSA-19-248-01 also covers CVE-2019-10996 (use after free), CVE-2019-10978 (out-of-bounds memory access) and CVE-2019-10990 (hard-coded file protection key). Our Red Lion Sixnet, N-Tron and Crimson guide lists the other Crimson families, and the memory corruption fix guide covers pointer bugs as a class. A later Crimson issue is CVE-2020-27285.

CVE-2019-10984 is not in the CISA KEV catalog as of 2026-11-22 (catalog version 2026.11.20, 1,790 entries). FIRST EPSS gives it 0.01006, the 63.9th percentile, in the 2026-11-21 dataset (CISA KEV, FIRST EPSS).

How to fix this class of issueThis advisory's weakness class is Memory corruption. Our practical guide covers how to detect, fix, verify and disclose it: How to fix memory corruption in embedded firmware.

Evidence

  • NVD (read 2026-11-22): status Modified, published 2019-09-23, last modified 2026-06-17; NVD Primary CVSS v3.1 7.8 AV:L/AC:L/PR:N/UI:R/S:U/C:H/I:H/A:H and CVSS v2 6.8; CISA ADP Secondary CVSS v3.1 7.8; NVD Primary CWE NVD-CWE-Other, ICS-CERT Secondary CWE-465; vulnerable CPE redlion crimson up to and including 3.0, and from 3.1 up to but excluding 3112.00. — NVD
  • CVE record (checked 2026-11-22): state PUBLISHED, CNA icscert, published 2019-09-23; CWE-465 pointer issues; product Red Lion Controls Crimson (Windows configuration software), version 3.0 and prior, version 3.1 prior to release 3112.00; no CNA CVSS score. — CVE.org
  • CISA CSAF ICSA-19-248-01 Red Lion Controls Crimson (2019-09-05), read 2026-11-22: reported by Michael DePlante, Anthony Fuller and Todd Manning of Trend Micro's Zero Day Initiative; known affected Crimson <= 3.0 and Crimson 3.1 before release 3112.00; fix: migrate to Crimson 3.1 release 3112.00 or later where the model choice allows; Red Lion security bulletin support.redlion.net article 360033077531; no known public exploits specifically target these vulnerabilities; CISA advises users to avoid social engineering (do not open untrusted attachments). CVE-2019-10984: CWE-824 access of uninitialized pointer, CVSS v3.0 7.8. — CISA CSAF ICSA-19-248-01
  • ZDI-19-786 and ZDI-19-789 (2019-09-05, read 2026-11-22): CVE-2019-10984, CVSS 7.8. ZDI-19-786: CD3 parsing, lack of proper initialization of a pointer prior to accessing it, code execution in the context of the current process. ZDI-19-789: CD31 parsing, lack of validation of a user-supplied value prior to dereferencing it as a pointer, code execution in the context of Administrator. Reported to vendor 2019-02-28. The ZDI 2019 list also maps ZDI-19-791 (CD3 untrusted pointer dereference) to this CVE. — Zero Day Initiative
  • Not in the CISA KEV catalog, version 2026.11.20 (1,790 entries), checked 2026-11-22. — CISA KEV
  • EPSS 0.01006, percentile 0.63854, dataset 2026-11-21, read 2026-11-22. — FIRST EPSS

Related advisories

Sources

  1. NVD
  2. CISA CSAF: ICSA-19-248-01 Red Lion Controls Crimson (machine-readable advisory)
  3. Zero Day Initiative ZDI-19-786: Red Lion Crimson CD3 file parsing uninitialized pointer
  4. Zero Day Initiative ZDI-19-789: Red Lion Crimson CD31 file parsing untrusted pointer dereference
  5. CVE.org record CVE-2019-10984 (CNA: ICS-CERT)
  6. CISA KEV
  7. FIRST EPSS
  8. Zero Day Initiative: published advisories 2019

Frequently asked questions

Which Crimson version fixes CVE-2019-10984?

Crimson 3.1 release 3112.00 or later. CISA's ICSA-19-248-01 lists Crimson 3.0 and earlier and Crimson 3.1 before release 3112.00 as affected and passes on Red Lion's advice to migrate where the device model allows it.

Why do the CWE labels differ between sources?

The ICS-CERT CNA record uses the broad category CWE-465 (pointer issues), CISA's CSAF file uses CWE-824 (access of uninitialized pointer) and NVD lists NVD-CWE-Other. ZDI's reports show both an uninitialised pointer and an untrusted pointer dereference, so no single CWE covers every case.

Does running Crimson as a standard user help?

It limits the damage. ZDI-19-789 says the attacker's code runs in the context of Administrator. On a standard Windows account, code running inside the Crimson process is held to that user's rights, which narrows what an attacker can change on the workstation until the update is installed.

Is CVE-2019-10984 exploited in the wild?

It is not in the CISA KEV catalog as of 2026-11-22 (catalog version 2026.11.20, 1,790 entries), and CISA reported no known public exploits specifically targeting it. FIRST EPSS gives it 0.01006 (63.9th percentile) in the 2026-11-21 dataset.