CVE-2020-19909 is a disputed integer overflow in the curl command-line tool: a very large --retry-delay value wrapped round, so curl retried sooner than asked. The curl project calls the report bogus and fixed the bug in curl 7.66.0 in 2019. NVD scores it 3.3 Low; Siemens lists it for S7-1500 MFP CPUs, fixed in V3.1.5.
Vulnerability summary
CVSS base score
3.3
Low severity
EPSS score (FIRST)
0.4%
Probability of exploitation in the wild in the next 30 days
CISA KEV catalog
No
Not listed
Published
Vulnerability ID: CVE-2020-19909 · Source: NVD
Affected components
| Component | CPE | Version range |
|---|---|---|
| curl command-line tool (--retry-delay, --retry-max-time) | cpe:2.3:a:haxx:curl:7.65.2:*:*:*:*:*:*:* | NVD CPE: curl 7.65.2 only; the bug existed in the tool before the fix, which shipped in curl 7.66.0 (2019-09-11). The curl project states no version is affected as a security issue |
| Debian curl package | pkg:deb/debian/curl | Fixed in 7.66.0-1 (unstable), urgency unimportant; bookworm, trixie, forky and sid listed as fixed (Debian security tracker, as of 2026-11-21) |
| Siemens SIMATIC S7-1500 CPU 1518-4 PN/DP MFP, CPU 1518F-4 PN/DP MFP and SIPLUS S7-1500 CPU 1518-4 PN/DP MFP (GNU/Linux subsystem) | — | V3.1.0 to before V3.1.5; update to V3.1.5 or later (Siemens SSA-398330, CISA ICSA-23-348-10) |
What does this mean for affected devices?
The NVD entry describes an "integer overflow vulnerability in tool_operate.c in curl 7.65.2 via a large value as the retry delay." The same record adds a NOTE that "many parties report that this has no direct security impact on the curl user", and that a denial of service to other systems is "not especially plausible because the overflow only happens if the user was trying to specify that curl should wait weeks (or longer)" before retrying. The CVE record was published on 2023-08-22 by MITRE as CNA, is in state PUBLISHED and carries the tag "disputed".
Why is CVE-2020-19909 disputed?
The curl project did not file this CVE and does not accept it. Its security page lists CVE-2020-19909 under "Bogus security vulnerabilities", issues "filed by others that are plain lies". The project's own CVE-2020-19909 page says "It does not affect any version. It is not a security problem", and records that MITRE denied the project's request to reject the ID, flagging the record as DISPUTED instead. MITRE's quoted reason is that the integer overflow "can lead to a valid security impact (denial of service, based on retrying network traffic much more often than is documented/requested)".
Daniel Stenberg's blog post of 2023-08-26 explains the bug. The --retry-delay option takes seconds and curl multiplied the value by 1000 to get milliseconds, so a value such as 18446744073709552 on a 64-bit system wrapped round and curl retried after a few minutes instead of waiting. On Windows, where a long is 32 bits, the overflow starts above about two million seconds (roughly 25 days). The issue was reported to the curl security team on 2019-07-27 and judged a plain bug. The post also says NVD first graded it 9.8 Critical.
What does the fix change?
Commit db0a0dfb ("curl: cap the maximum allowed values for retry time arguments", 2019-07-29, pull request 4166) makes --retry-delay and --retry-max-time reject values above LONG_MAX/1000 with a "number too large" error and adds test 1269. It touches only the command-line tool's sources (src/tool_getparam.c, src/tool_paramhlp.c), not libcurl. The fix shipped in curl 7.66.0 on 2019-09-11.
How severe is CVE-2020-19909?
NVD's Primary score is now CVSS v3.1 3.3 Low (CVSS:3.1/AV:L/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:N/I:N/A:L) with CWE-190, Integer Overflow or Wraparound. MITRE as CNA gives no score. CISA's SSVC entry records exploitation "none", automatable "no" and technical impact "partial". NVD's CPE match is curl 7.65.2 only. The local vector fits the bug: the value comes from whoever writes the curl command line or script, and the worst outcome is retries sooner than intended.
Which devices list CVE-2020-19909?
Scanners match the CVE against any curl package, so it shows up in firmware SBOMs even where only libcurl is shipped. Siemens ProductCERT SSA-398330 (V2.8, last updated 2026-10-13) lists it for the additional GNU/Linux subsystem of the SIMATIC S7-1500 CPU 1518-4 PN/DP MFP, CPU 1518F-4 PN/DP MFP and SIPLUS S7-1500 CPU 1518-4 PN/DP MFP, firmware V3.1.0 to before V3.1.5. Siemens scores it 3.3 with the same base vector and recommends updating to V3.1.5 or later; it says the V3.1 line is no longer maintained and the CVE list there will not be updated. CISA's CSAF republication ICSA-23-348-10 lists the same five order numbers, the same fix and the mitigation "Only build and run applications from trusted sources."
On the distribution side, the Debian security tracker marks the issue unimportant, "Crash in CLI tool, no security impact", fixed in curl 7.66.0-1 in unstable, with bookworm, trixie, forky and sid listed as fixed as of 2026-11-21.
How do you fix CVE-2020-19909?
Any curl at 7.66.0 or later carries the cap. On a Siemens S7-1500 MFP CPU, update to V3.1.5 or later as SSA-398330 recommends; the same update clears the other GNU/Linux subsystem CVEs in that advisory, such as CVE-2019-3863 in libssh2. If a firmware image ships only libcurl and no curl binary, the code path in the fix is not present. When an SBOM triage needs a recorded decision, cite the curl project page and the NOTE in the CVE record. Our libcurl vulnerabilities in embedded firmware guide explains how to separate real curl findings from disputed and rejected ones; curl issues that do matter on devices include CVE-2023-38545, CVE-2023-38546 and CVE-2024-6197.
Is CVE-2020-19909 exploited?
It is not in the CISA KEV catalog as of 2026-11-21 (catalog version 2026.11.20, 1,790 entries). FIRST EPSS gives it 0.00367, the 31.3rd percentile, in the 2026-11-20 dataset (CISA KEV, FIRST EPSS).
Evidence
- NVD (read 2026-11-21): status Modified, tag disputed; published 2023-08-22; NVD Primary CVSS v3.1 3.3 CVSS:3.1/AV:L/AC:L/PR:L/UI:N/S:U/C:N/I:N/A:L; CWE-190 (NVD Primary); CPE haxx:curl 7.65.2; CISA ADP SSVC exploitation none, automatable no, technical impact partial; references curl PR 4166, Stenberg blog post and Siemens SSA-398330. — NVD
- CVE record (read 2026-11-21): state PUBLISHED, CNA MITRE, published 2023-08-22, tag disputed, NOTE on no direct security impact; no CNA CVSS score. — CVE.org
- curl security page and CVE-2020-19909 page (read 2026-11-21): listed under 'Bogus security vulnerabilities ... plain lies'; 'It does not affect any version. It is not a security problem'; MITRE denied rejection and flagged it DISPUTED; reported 2019-07-27, fixed 2019-07-29, shipped in curl 7.66.0 on 2019-09-11. — curl project
- Daniel Stenberg blog post 2023-08-26 (read 2026-11-21): --retry-delay seconds multiplied by 1000; 18446744073709552 on 64-bit overflowed (384 seconds in the example); on Windows 32-bit longs overflow above about two million seconds (roughly 25 days); NVD originally graded it 9.8 Critical. — daniel.haxx.se
- curl commit db0a0dfb (2019-07-29, closes #4166, reported by Jason Lee): str2unummax caps --retry-delay and --retry-max-time at LONG_MAX/1000; changes src/tool_getparam.c, src/tool_paramhlp.c, src/tool_paramhlp.h and adds test 1269. — curl repository
- Siemens SSA-398330 V2.8 (last update 2026-10-13, read 2026-11-21): CVE-2020-19909 listed for SIMATIC S7-1500 CPU 1518(F)-4 PN/DP MFP and SIPLUS variant >= V3.1.0 < V3.1.5; CVSS v3.1 3.3, CWE-190; update to V3.1.5 or later; V3.1 line no longer maintained, CVE list not updated further. — Siemens ProductCERT
- CISA CSAF ICSA-23-348-10 (version 18, 2025-08-12, read 2026-11-21): CVE-2020-19909 known_affected for five order numbers 6ES7518-4AX00-1AB0/1AC0, 6ES7518-4FX00-1AB0/1AC0, 6AG1518-4AX00-4AC0; vendor_fix update to V3.1.5; mitigation 'Only build and run applications from trusted sources.' — CISA
- Debian security tracker (read 2026-11-21): curl fixed in 7.66.0-1 (unstable), unimportant, note 'Crash in CLI tool, no security impact'; bookworm, trixie, forky, sid fixed. — Debian
- Not in the CISA KEV catalog, version 2026.11.20 (1,790 entries), checked 2026-11-21. — CISA KEV
- EPSS 0.00367, percentile 0.31337, dataset 2026-11-20, read 2026-11-21. — FIRST EPSS

Related advisories
Sources
- NVD
- CVE.org record CVE-2020-19909 (CNA: MITRE, disputed)
- curl project: CVE-2020-19909, bogus report filed by anonymous
- curl project: security overview (retracted and bogus CVEs)
- Daniel Stenberg: CVE-2020-19909 is everything that is wrong with CVEs
- curl commit db0a0dfb: cap the maximum allowed values for retry time arguments
- Siemens ProductCERT SSA-398330: GNU/Linux subsystem of SIMATIC S7-1500 CPU 1518(F)-4 PN/DP MFP
- CISA CSAF ICSA-23-348-10: Siemens SIMATIC S7-1500
- Debian security tracker: CVE-2020-19909
- CISA KEV
- FIRST EPSS
Frequently asked questions
Is CVE-2020-19909 a real vulnerability?
It is a real bug but a disputed vulnerability. The curl project says it does not affect any version as a security problem; MITRE kept the CVE, flagged DISPUTED, on the grounds that wrong retry timing could in theory flood another system. NVD scores it 3.3 Low.
Does CVE-2020-19909 affect libcurl in firmware?
The fix commit changes only the curl command-line tool's option parsing for --retry-delay and --retry-max-time, not libcurl. A firmware image that ships libcurl without the curl binary does not contain that code path, although scanners may still report the CVE against the package.
Which curl version fixes CVE-2020-19909?
curl 7.66.0, released on 2019-09-11, caps both retry options at LONG_MAX/1000 and rejects larger values. Debian lists the fix in 7.66.0-1 and rates the issue unimportant.
What should Siemens S7-1500 MFP users do?
Siemens SSA-398330 lists the CPU 1518-4 PN/DP MFP, CPU 1518F-4 PN/DP MFP and SIPLUS variant at V3.1.0 to before V3.1.5 and recommends V3.1.5 or later. That update also covers the other GNU/Linux subsystem CVEs in the same advisory.
Questions about this page?